Chapter 36: Why the South Votes Republican

I’ve thought a lot about this over the last few days as we head to another election.  For Progressive’s like me, it’s forecast to be a rough one who’s results may lead us backward as opposed to foreward.

And, once again, the South will lead us there.  We’ve always been good at looking fondly backward in the South–whether the facts support it or not.

That got me thinking.  Why is it the South is such a stronghold for the Republicans?  Here are my thoughts:

  1. The South is heavy with fundamentalists and evangelical religions.  These people have been played by the Republican Party like a cheap violin.  Here is what I would say to them:  Open your eyes.  Under Bush, the Republicans controlled the government and did not ban abortion or execute any of the other points of your agenda.  If they didn’t do it then, they won’t do it now.  They are using you.  Wise up.
  2. There is a history of Patriarchy in the South that is not dead.  The poor folks in the South have a genetic memory of listening to the Overseer or the Mill Boss.  They still follow the dictates of local political leaders with little thought.  They are used to being led without questions.  See:  The Civil War.
  3. Education is not really valued by a large portion of Southerners.  They are suspicious of the overly educated and think they don’t understand them.  The Republicans are very good at playing dumb and coming off as one of the “good ole boys” while they use the votes of the poor whites in the South to channel money and benefits to their rich friends on Wall Street.
  4. Southerners never look at anything too deeply.  That explains number 1, above, and a lot of other things about the South.  Introspection is not valued in the South.  Action is….The Republican’s play on this very well.
  5. Facts don’t mean much in the South.  Truth has always been conceptual rather than a reality.  Any region that can convince itself for over 150 years that the Civil War was about “states rights” rather than slavery is capable of any kind of self-delusion.
  6. States Rights are tied to the myth of the Old South, so the South tends to hate the idea of Big Government, even if they enjoy the benefits.  They can over look little things like Social Security, Medicare, new bridges and highways, insurance that covers pre-existing conditions and college kids.  They somehow don’t make the connection that the federal government provides these things…
  7. Southerners value personal freedom above all else, as long as you are a straight white man.
  8. The President is Black and he’s a Democrat.  To a large group of folks in the South, this alone is enough reason to vote Republican.  Although you may never get them to admit it…

What can Democrats do to change all this and win the South?

  1. Learn to fight.  The South and most of the Country values people who stand up for their principles.  The GOP has Balls and the Democrats have Brains.  You have to have both to win in the South.
  2. Push for independent, bipartisan redistricting commissions.
  3. Get out your message.  We’ve got to publicize the benefits of the legislation we do pass and how it helps the poor and middle class as opposed to the Rich.  The Democrats and The President have failed miserably at this for the last 2 years.  We have real achievements, but no one knows it.
  4. Take on the bullies at Fox News.  We have got to make people realize this is not a news organization, but a propaganda machine that provides entertainment to the ignorant.  We should be pushing companies not to advertise on Fox News.  We should be telling the Management to turn it off in Public places like restaraunts and gyms.
  5. Call a liar a liar.  This relates to number 1, but I can’t stress this enough.  The Republicans look right in the camera and lie.  And no one calls them on it.  We have to start making people aware that there are things called “Facts” and stand up for them.
  6. Make this about Class Warfare.  A class war is going on and most of the country doesn’t realized it.  And the Republicans started it.  Call’em on it.  While the top 1% of American households holds 34.6% of all privately-held wealth, for example, the bottom 80% (made up of salary workers) holds 14.9%.  Tax policy greatly benefits the wealthy and the Bush Tax Cuts need to end for this group.
  7. Make it clear:  Unless you have an individual income of greater than $200,000 or a combined Family income of over $300,000, there is absolutely no financial reason to vote for the Republicans.  If you want to vote for what is best for your pocketbook, vote for the Democrats.  They will- and have- cut your taxes, while the Republicans focus on the Corporations and the wealthy.
  8. Make Obama white.  That’s about the only way you can get about 35% of white Southerners to support the Democrats.  We have to focus on the remaining 65% of the South with open minds.
  9. Wait it out….The older, closed minded, prejudiced Southerners are dying off.  The younger ones are better educated and have seen more of the world.  Those are the Southern Democrats of tomorrow.
  10. Make your Democratic friends vote.  Even if you have to go to their house or job and throw them in the car and take them to the polls.  There are more Democrats than Republicans in many parts of the South.  The problem is Republicans always vote and Democrats don’t.  If more Democrats would actually just show up at the polls, we would win a lot more races.

Those are my thoughts for now.

All I have left to say is:

If you are a Democrat, get off your butt and vote.  There are no excuses.

If you are a Republican-why don’t you just book a spa day for Tuesday and let the election go?  You won’t be missed….

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to Chapter 36: Why the South Votes Republican

  1. Tim Flowers says:

    Interesting comments. However, it does paint all Southerners with a rather broad brush. The South is far more diverse than it was just 20 years ago due to better education and an influx of people from other parts of the country and other nations.

    The issue facing the entire country, and not just the South, is that our population is increasingly weighed down by the challenges of life. Our society has gotten so complex that simply surviving from day to day has become a gauntlet of taxes, fees, living expenses, transportation, insurance, healthcare, jobs with virtually slave-era atmospheres, toxic food, and on and on. By the time we’ve survived all this every day, self-education about current affairs seems like just more work, so we turn on Fox News, American Idol, or a football game instead. We’ve had enough…we just want to zone out for a couple of hours before the process starts all over again.

    Both Democratic and Republican politicians play us for fools and add to our burdens while taking our money and freedom away for the benefit of themselves and their rich friends. Granted, Democrats are less harmful than Republicans, but both sides are in the game; different sides of the same coin, perhaps.

  2. Lee Zacharias says:

    The South voted as solidly Democratic before Lyndon Johnson signed the Civil Rights Act in 1964 as it now does Republican. It doesn’t take a rocket scientist to figure out why the shift. Despite all our “racial progress.”

  3. Bruce Wilmot says:

    I hardly know where to begin. But I gotta start somewhere, so I’ll do it with tax policy.

    I fail to see how across-the-board tax cuts are unfair to anybody. Sure, the “rich” get to keep more dollars than those who are less rich. That’s because the wealthier pay more — much more — in the first place.

    Some facts: The top 50% of income earners pay 97% of federal income taxes; the bottom 50% pay 3%. … The top 1% of income earners pay 34%. So much for the wealthier not paying their “fair share.” Whatever that is.

    When people, particularly small business people, are allowed to keep more of their money, they can spend more, invest more, hire more. This is a MUCH more efficient and effective way to improve an economy than any other known to man. Small businesses are still responsible for about 2/3 of the hiring in this country.

    The “stimulus” is nothing more than taking money from more productive sectors of the economy and putting it into other, probably less productive, areas.

    More and more, we are becoming a country of takers instead of producers.

    As for those who say the economic meltdown from which we are now suffering is the result of unfettered capitalism, well, they’re wrong. The government played a huge role in creating the housing bubble that led to the mess. Not the only role, but an essential one. As a result, we now have a much bigger and much more expensive federal government. And that’s not the answer.

  4. gail says:

    Oh, boy, I could debate the *slavery was the cause of the Civil War* theory forever. I taught my children the truth, that their teachers didn’t know squat about history (that’s another story, how I had to go to the principal’s office to explain to all the 5th. grade teachers). Abraham Lincoln wasn’t against slavery, he was against slavery spreading to new territories. And Abraham Lincoln was a Republican. Enough said.

  5. Having never lived in the south I am no expert on this subject. I will say however that the difference between the 2 partys today is simple, the Republicans have always been the party of blame which is easy to do while the Democrates have been the party of dreams. If the republicans wish to make things fair the they should pass a law stating that a state can only get back what it puts into the pot. If your state pays federal taxes of one dollar then you as a state can’t get back more than a dollar. Once we relieve the inequity of each states return then there will be no more Republican party. The states that receive more than 1for 1 are almost all red states and just that balance of payment will be felt by those that really don’t know what the Democrats have done for them.

  6. Jen says:

    This is piece is dripping with condescension and ignorance. It seems as though you choose to ignore actual history and make up your own version just to get in a little “snark”. You seem like a nice guy but you have NO idea what you’re blogging about…

  7. Asher says:

    This chapter is excellent and very to the point, thanks for this!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s